SpruanceQuarterly

Contact us today

About SpruanceQuarterly...

SpruanceQuarterly

The SpruanceQuarterly newsletter provides unique insights into leadership, strategy, product marketing and pricing topics. Join the thousands of others who look to this important Spruance Group publication for cutting edge ideas and provocative commentary. Signup today for your complementary subscription.

Contact us today

Reader Favorites...

Customers don't care about your stinking costs
Customers don't care about your stinking costs - If customers don’t care about costs, why do so many firms today put so much emphasis on cost when determining price? The answer is that these same firms don’t really understand the value of the products and services they provide to their customers and because of this, they take the lazy approach. Read more >>

Innovation and critical thinking
Innovation and the importance of critical thinking - Relying on intuition alone to make the decisions necessary for a successful innovation project is a bad strategy. Critical thinking--the most important skillset an innovator needs to possess--is what determines success from failure in today's innovation environment. Read more >>

Apple
Apple's questionable pricing strategy - Apple has always been a brand that fiercely protected their pricing strategy. So why did they discount their latest OS release by almost 80% from their previous version? Read more >>

Basketball's disruptive innovation

Print view (PDF)

By Patrick Lefler                                                                         

 Of all the changes that have occurred in basketball since James Naismith invented the game 120 years ago, which is considered the game’s most important? The dunk? The shot clock? The Laker Girls? All are significant, but this particular innovation could also be considered one of basketball’s true innovations—a game changer that revolutionized the sport so dramatically that the previous way of performing this act became obsolete. Give up?

It was the jump shot. Yes, the jump shot—a way of shooting that, while once novel, is taken for granted today.

For the first forty years of its history, basketball was a slow-paced game where shooting was confined to the “set shot”—a shot where players used one or both hands to shoot while keeping their feet firmly on the floor. There was very little jumping; current thinking at the time was that shots could only be accurate if the player was set in one place, as with a free throw. The idea of players jumping and shooting at the same time just was unheard of.

All that changed in the early 1940s when Kenny Sailors played for the University of Wyoming. According to author John Christgau, author of the book Origins of the Jump Shot, Sailors was one of the earliest (if not the first) to use the jump shot as a young boy growing up in rural Wyoming:

He was born in Nebraska in 1923, and at an early age moved with his mother and older brother Bud to a farm on the bleak Wyoming prairie east of Cheyenne. There, the family scratched out a living on a small farm during the depths of the Depression. “Boys,” Cora Belle Sailors directed her two sons during frigid winters, “go out and get some fuel.” That meant either cow chips gathered off the prairie, or roadside pieces of rubber tire that would burn with a fierce heat. Cora Sailors also instilled in her two sons a curious combination of fatalism and determination. “Lord,” she would end the prayers at the supper table, “not my will, but Yours.” Then she would lecture them. “It doesn't make any difference if you get knocked down seven times. You get back up.”

By early 1934, at six-five Bud Sailors was one of the tallest people anybody on the prairie around Cheyenne had ever seen. At the end of his junior year at Hillsdale High, his coach loaned him a school ball to practice with over the summer. Bud nailed a hoop to the side of their farm windmill, and he and his little brother Kenny, four years younger and a foot short than Bud, began fierce one-on-one games.

Bud’s strategy was merely to sit back and wait until Kenny tried to shoot, then slap the ball back in his little brother’s face. His mother’s homily about perseverance fresh in his mind, Kenny was soon taking his first jump shots at the windmill basket in May of 1934. They were desperate, leaping efforts to try to avoid having the ball batted away by his towering brother. Eventually, the shot became unstoppable, against tall men or short, and Kenny Sailors went from high school straight to the University of Wyoming, where he became an All American and one of the leaders of the 1943 NCAA champs. His jump shots in the finals against Georgetown are considered the first ones ever taken in Madison Square Garden.

Kenny Sailors’ jump shot shares all the characteristics of disruptive innovation:

  1. It changed the existing ecosystem. Sailors’ new shot changed the way that players and coaches viewed shooting. As more and more players adopted the jump shot, refinements continued over time until we got the modern jump shot of today. And on the opposite side of the coin, the jump shot changed the way that teams played defense.
  2. Early adoption created a huge competitive advantage. The University of Wyoming was the first to use Sailors’ jump shot and they won the NCAA championship—their only national championship in basketball.
  3. It disrupted and replaced the existing offering in the market. Almost overnight, the jump shot replaced the set shot, sending it into obsolescence. In fact, most basketball players and fans today have never even seen a set shot.

Innovation comes in many different forms. For Kenny Sailors, improving the existing set shot was not the answer in his quest to win backyard scrimmages with his brother; the only way to achieve victory was through disruptive innovation, exemplified by the jump shot. For all those who grew up watching the classic shooters Michael Jordan, Reggie Miller, Larry Bird and Jerry West perform their magic, a big “thank you” should go to Kenny Sailors, who was the first to use the shot on a national stage.


The Spruance Group Patrick Lefler is the founder of The Spruance Group; a management consulting firm that helps growing companies grow dramatically faster. He is a former Marine Corps officer and a graduate of both Annapolis and The Wharton School. The Spruance Group acts as a trusted partner by offering unbiased advice and providing unique solutions to help clients solve their most pressing product strategy needs. For more information, visit www.spruancegroup.com or contact Patrick at: plefler@spruancegroup.com 
JBHCWXG7DY3H